The Employment and Labour Relations Court has dismissed an appeal by the Teachers Service Commission (TSC) against a magistrate’s decision that awarded a former teacher Sh975,000 for unfair dismissal. The court found that the Commission had not established the allegations that led to his dismissal.
The teacher, Dominic Mwanzia Musyoka, lost his job in 2018 after he was accused of sexually harassing a minor at a secondary school in Makueni County.
What the court decided
The court agreed with the magistrate that the dismissal was substantively unfair. It held that TSC, as the employer, had a duty to justify the serious allegations of sexual harassment against the teacher, and that it failed to do so.
‘The Appellant therefore had a duty to justify those serious allegations of sexual harassment against the Respondent,’ the judge ruled.
How the Sh975,000 is made up
| Component | Amount (Sh) |
|---|---|
| Salary in place of notice | 75,000 |
| Compensation for unfair termination (12 months’ salary) | 900,000 |
| Total | 975,000 |
The calculation: 75,000 + 900,000 = 975,000. The 12-month compensation matches 12 × a monthly salary of Sh75,000.
A different outcome in another case
Courts decide teacher dismissal cases on the evidence before them. In a separate case decided in December 2025, the Employment and Labour Relations Court in Nairobi upheld TSC’s dismissal of a secondary school teacher accused of sexually harassing a pupil. The court found that the pupil and other witnesses testified in the teacher’s presence and that he had cross-examined them. It declined reinstatement or compensation, saying that returning a teacher found guilty of sexual misconduct to the classroom would undermine learners’ safety.
TSC’s duty to learners
TSC remains responsible for the discipline of teachers and for protecting learners. The Court of Appeal ruled in 2020 that the Commission can be held liable for sexual misconduct by teachers against learners.

