Ayabei’s TSC Appointment Sparks Tribalism Debate as Commission Defends Merit-Based Selection

By Hezron Rooy·5 hours ago·6 min read
TSC chairman Dr Jamleck Muturi John
Text size

The Teachers Service Commission has rejected claims that Cheptumo Ayabei’s appointment as Secretary and Chief Executive Officer was influenced by tribalism, saying he emerged as the best candidate in a competitive recruitment exercise.

The commission’s response follows criticism over ethnic representation, questions about Evaleen Mitei’s non-selection and competing reactions in online teacher forums. Other contributions welcomed Ayabei’s experience and described his appointment as an important step for disability inclusion.

TSC chairman Dr Jamleck Muturi John said the commission followed the law and appointed Ayabei on merit, with his appointment taking effect on 16 November 2026.

Tribalism allegations draw a direct response from TSC

Questions about ethnic representation became a prominent part of the public response to the appointment.

Comments indexed beneath TSC’s announcement included complaints about appointments going to ‘one community’. On Teachers Updates’ earlier Facebook discussion of the shortlist, a contributor similarly wrote: ‘One community is dominating.’

The criticism extended beyond teacher forums. Former Deputy President Rigathi Gachagua alleged that the appointment reflected tribalism, prompting a direct rebuttal from the commission.

‘We are mandated to recruit the CEO of TSC. We follow procedures,’ Muturi said during a press briefing on 17 November.

He maintained that Ayabei had been selected through interviews rather than outside direction.

‘Cheptumo was the best and was appointed CEO. He had a sterling career at TSC, where he joined as a finance officer before rising to Director of Finance and Accounts,’ the commission said.

In its written clarification, TSC said transparency, accountability, fair competition and merit guided the recruitment.

‘On behalf of the Commission, I want to assure the teachers of this Country and the general public that the process of the recruitment of the Commission Secretary has been conducted in a transparent, accountable and verifiable manner strictly in accordance with the law,’ Muturi stated.

The commission’s position directly challenges the allegation that ethnic identity determined the outcome. Public comments about a candidate’s perceived community background do not, by themselves, establish how the appointment was made.

Mwaura rejects ethnic profiling and defends disability inclusion

The Head of the Office of Diversity, Inclusion and Disability Rights, Isaac Mwaura, also defended Ayabei’s appointment, calling for an end to ethnic profiling in public recruitment.

‘His tribe is disability,’ Mwaura said during a briefing at Harambee Annex in Nairobi.

Mwaura argued that Ayabei’s professional record and recruitment performance should take precedence over attempts to reduce the appointment to ethnic identity.

He said qualified persons with disabilities had long been overlooked for senior responsibilities and described the appointment as an opportunity for substantive inclusion in institutional leadership and decision-making.

His intervention echoed positive responses in teacher discussion groups, including the message: ‘Disability is not inability, congratulations to the new tsc CEO cheptumo Ayabei.’

Other posts highlighted the significance of his progression for children and professionals living with disabilities.

Mitei’s non-selection remains a major question

Alongside the tribalism debate, contributors questioned why Mitei had not been confirmed after leading the commission in an acting capacity.

‘Mitei was well with teacher and unionists. Why not her?’ one asked beneath a Facebook appointment announcement.

Another public response questioned why she had discharged the office’s responsibilities for more than a year without securing the substantive appointment, while acknowledging that acting service did not guarantee selection.

A separate post described Mitei as ‘the real deal’ before congratulating Ayabei. Another characterised her as ‘shortchanged’.

These reactions place her perceived relationship with teachers and experience in the acting position at the centre of the argument for continuity.

TSC’s answer is that Ayabei emerged best among the five candidates interviewed. Its statement does not establish that Mitei’s acting service entitled her to confirmation, nor do the comments establish a breach of recruitment rules.

The appointment ends Mitei’s acting tenure as CEO; it does not mean she has left the commission.

Gender becomes part of the discussion

Gender representation has also featured in public reactions, although the comments do not point in one direction.

‘We need gender balance in CEO position,’ one Facebook contribution stated before congratulating Ayabei. Other comments favouring Mitei focused on her relationship with teachers rather than her gender.

Mwaura introduced a separate historical argument. He said Ayabei had emerged top in an earlier recruitment exercise that resulted in Nancy Macharia’s appointment, but claimed gender considerations had favoured Macharia. That account remains attributed to Mwaura; it is not a publication of the earlier recruitment records.

For the current exercise, TSC’s stated position is that Ayabei emerged as the best candidate.

Experience attracts confidence—and scrutiny

Ayabei’s long service has been cited in messages welcoming the appointment.

In its latest statement, TSC said he joined as a Finance Officer in 1999, became Director of Finance in 2011 and Director of Finance and Accounts in 2015. The commission attributed his progression to work ethic, performance, professionalism and dedication.

However, his finance background also prompted questions about the experience required to lead the teaching service.

‘Have seen more of accountant his he a teacher,’ a contributor asked under a post listing his qualifications.

TSC’s biography lists a Bachelor of Education, Arts option, from Kenyatta University, an MSc in Finance and Banking and CPA(K) qualifications. His academic background therefore extends beyond accountancy.

Some goodwill was explicitly conditional. One public discussion congratulated Ayabei while stating that ‘the teaching fraternity is watching’.

Commission rejects fraudulent interview document

TSC separately disowned a document circulated as its CEO interview results, declaring it fake and misleading.

The commission directed the public to its official website and verified social media channels for authentic information. The fraudulent document cannot be used as evidence of the candidates’ performance or the validity of the appointment.

TSC’s official position remains that Ayabei emerged best among the five candidates.

Court cases delayed the appointment

Responding to questions about the lengthy recruitment, TSC said two court cases interrupted the exercise.

The commission first advertised the position on 6 May 2025. A court order dated 25 May halted the process. On 29 January 2026, the court dismissed the application and directed recruitment to resume from the point of suspension.

A second order, issued on 3 February 2026, stopped the exercise again. The High Court directed fresh recruitment on 17 September, after which TSC readvertised the position on 29 September.

The commission received 124 applications, shortlisted five candidates and conducted interviews on 16 November.

Employment-letter concerns add to the confidence test

Some appointment-related discussions also raised allegations about access to employment and promotion letters. Those comments are not established findings, but they show that recruitment fairness remains part of the wider conversation.

The concerns follow the separate dispute over claims that teacher appointment letters were distributed through State House and MPs.

TSC rejected those claims and maintained that recruitment and issuance of appointment letters fall within its mandate. The matter also featured in National Assembly proceedings on 14 October 2026.

That controversy does not establish wrongdoing by Ayabei. It does, however, form part of the institutional background against which some contributors are assessing the incoming administration.

Focus turns to delivery

The visible reactions encompass ethnic representation, recognition of Mitei’s acting service, disability inclusion, professional qualifications and confidence in recruitment. They are not a representative survey of all Kenyan teachers.

TSC has responded by defending merit, explaining the recruitment chronology and rejecting fraudulent information. Mwaura has added a separate defence centred on disability inclusion and opposition to ethnic profiling.

Ayabei now takes responsibility for a mandate that includes stronger governance, improved service delivery and teacher professionalism. Those responsibilities provide the practical basis for assessing his leadership beyond the appointment debate.

Related reading on Teachers Updates

Related articles